Ethical Veganism: The New Ruling and what Change may need to be implemented for businesses
Published: February 4, 2020
Author: admin

A Norwich Employment Tribunal decision has accepted ethical veganism as a philosophical belief to be protected under the Equality Act 2010.

A recent judgment at an Employment Tribunal in Norwich marked a new ruling that “ethical veganism” is recognised as a philosophical belief, and is therefore a protected characteristic under the Equality Act 2010 against discrimination. Jordi Casamitjana brought an unfair dismissal claim against his employer, League Against Cruel Sports (LACS), after he raised concerns with colleagues that its pension fund invested in companies involving animal testing. Ethical vegans eat a plant-based diet and also try to avoid contact with products derived from any form of animal exploitation, such as avoiding wearing wool or leather and not using products tested on animals.

The Ruling:

Judge Robin Postle ruled that ethical veganism does qualify as a philosophical belief by applying the criteria set out in Campbell and Cosans v United Kingdom, [1982], and the Equality Act 2010:

• The belief must be genuinely held;
• it must be a belief and not an opinion or viewpoint based on the present state of information available;
• it must be a belief as to a weighty and substantial aspect of human life and behaviour;
• it must attain a certain level of cogency, seriousness, cohesion and importance;
• and be worthy of respect in a democratic society, compatible with human dignity and not conflict with the fundamental rights of others.

After having his employment terminated when he notified his colleagues, Mr Casamitjana argued that his termination was unfair discipline due to his ethical veganism and that he was discriminated against on the basis of his beliefs. The League Against Cruel Sports argued that Mr Casamitjana was terminated for gross misconduct.

Mr Casamitjana argued that where all lifestyle decisions are viewed through the lens of avoiding exploitation or killing of animals that a cogent argument can be made that ethical veganism is suitable for legal protection. The Employment tribunal has not yet ruled on the issue of his dismissal, which the League Against Cruel Sports maintains is for gross misconduct and not for his beliefs.

The effect of the Ruling:

Whilst this would be considered a landmark ruling, it does not change the law in any way; the ruling is a judgment of the first instance and it is important to bear in mind that this does not need to be followed. Where the ruling has made an impact however, is the fact that businesses should now consider how best to accommodate ethical veganism.

First and foremost, business owners should create a culture of understanding and respect in the workplace by ensuring that they, and their staff, are educated on, and fully understand what it means to be ethically vegan. It was found that 74% of UK employers do not realise that “philosophical beliefs” (along with religious beliefs) are protected under the Equality Act 2010 which could potentially open up employers to claims of discrimination. Ethical vegans follow a lifestyle and make choices which are shaped by their desire to avoid cruelty and suffering to animals at all practical costs, and therefore, necessary training should be given to employers and employees which enables them to better consider how to avoid discrimination against ethical vegans.

Business owners should keep a close eye on their staff and be aware of anything which might be said or done to cause offence between staff. Whilst friendly banter or mild teasing might be common in some workplaces, employers should ensure that they step in where they feel it is appropriate. If necessary, point your staff to your bullying and harassment policy so that they are reminded of what would be considered bullying and harassment in the workplace.

Remember that discrimination is treating someone less favourably because of a protected characteristic; businesses should aim to be as accommodating as possible if they have any vegan staff and ensure that all staff feel welcome, safe and respected within their working environment.

Silenced by Fear: A Guide to Addressing Sexual Harassment from Those in Power

Introduction Sexual harassment can occur in many contexts, not just in the workplace. When the harasser is in a position of power—be it a manager, investor, joint venture partner, or any influential figure—it can create a climate of fear that discourages victims from...

From partners to rivals | Protecting your company using restrictive covenants

If a founder or shareholders or senior managers relationship sours, things can go wrong very quickly causing the company distraction and financial losses. This is compounded if on exit the departing individual seeks to poach clients or staff seeks to work with a...

Navigating Fashion’s Legal Landscape: Essential Guidance for Designers and Entrepreneurs

Introduction: Fashion Week is more than just runways and glamorous designs it's also a pivotal time for designers, entrepreneurs, and brands to reassess their legal strategies. As the fashion industry faces unique challenges heading into 2025, including new...

From Partners to Rivals: Protecting Your Company through restrictive covenants

Today, we’re tackling an issue that can make or break your business—restrictive covenants and their role in protecting your company during shareholder, director or staff disputes. We will touch on their importance, how these should be incorporated into your documents...

Protecting AI Innovations: Strategies and Guidelines – Part 2

As Artificial intelligence (AI) continues to evolve, its intersection with Intellectual Property (IP) law has become a crucial consideration for innovators. The UK Intellectual Property Office (IPO) has a set of detailed guidelines to evaluate if AI inventions are...

The Life of a Disruptive Lawyer: Innovating Legal Practice in Emerging Technologies ran by a Mum & Female Founder

In the staid and often stolid world of law, disruption is not a term often associated with the legal profession. Yet, at A City Law Firm , disruption is our modus operandi. From pioneering payment plans to engaging with cutting-edge technology, we have redefined what...

Protecting AI Innovations: Strategies and Guidelines – Part 1

As Artificial intelligence (AI) continues to evolve, its intersection with Intellectual Property (IP) law has become a crucial consideration for innovators. The UK Intellectual Property Office (IPO) has a set of detailed guidelines to evaluate if AI inventions are...

Tackling workplace toxicity

In today’s interconnected work environment, whether through face-to-face interactions, virtual meetings on Teams, or other communication platforms, issues such as derogatory comments, bad-mouthing employers and management, bullying and discrimination are prevalent....

Navigating the metaverse | Potential challenges for employers and employees in the UK

With the rapid advancement of technology, the concept of the metaverse is no longer confined to the realm of science fiction it is here. As virtual reality, augmented reality, and other immersive technologies converge, the metaverse is becoming increasingly tangible....

IP Licenses: When do you need one and what are the essential terms it must have?

As technology lawyers working in emerging technology, our biggest value is protecting and commercialising the founders IP The why ? In the fast-paced world of intellectual property (IP), safeguarding your creations is paramount. Whether you’re an inventor, artist, or...