How Emojis Are Creeping Into The Courtroom
Published: February 28, 2019
Author: admin


Jurisdictions around the world are starting to recognise that the law must evolve in conjuncture with language and digital communication.

Until now, courts have traditionally relied on hard evidence such as documents, words, audio and video recordings as evidence. However, the strong influence of popular culture and widespread use of Emoji as an enhancement to language means that it has been necessary for the courts to cast the evidential net much wider.

People use Emoji’s in conjunction with words, to demonstrate emotion, mindset, tone, intention and mood. It seems very likely that their use within the courtroom will continue to increase and it seems reasonable to assume that British courts will increasingly consider and draw inferences from Emojis in evidence, especially given their ability to convey intent behind civil action and criminal charges. How far this goes is yet to be seen.

Judge Uses Emoji In English Court Judgement

Interestingly, electronic databases such as Westlaw or Lexis aren’t currently set up to handle or display Emojis.
However, a recent family court ruling handed down by Mr Justice Peter Jackson, which is thought to be the first in English legal history to incorporate an Emoji, or web symbol, to explain a point of evidence, incorporated an Emoji in his judgment.

A judgment is the kind of document in which one might expect to find daunting legal terminology, interspersed with Latin phrases or even a smattering of Norman French. But one High Court judge has gone to previously unheard-of lengths to make a judgment in a family court case comprehensible even for the children it affects – by replacing dry terminology with a battery of down-to-earth phrases and even a smiley face symbol.

The use of an Emoji by a judge is clearly novel, but it seems very likely that this will not be the only case of its kind, as future judges will also choose to incorporate them descriptively into their future judgments, as the prevalence of Emoji’s in modern day communication continues to grow.

In the meantime, there is a need to recognise the impact of technology on court procedures and processes including how this additional body of evidence can have the potential to shape the outcome of proceedings and even be used to help in describing their outcomes.

As Lady Justice Arden prudently notes in Common Law And Modern Society: Keeping Pace With Change;

“The law cannot stand still. It must keep pace with changes in society. The law provides the framework within which members of society and economic actors operate. It provides guidance for endeavours, public and private, and sets the parameters of lawful behaviour. If the law falls behind the times, it cannot perform these functions properly.

It is an undoubted fact that societies evolve, and that considerable change has occurred since the 1990s in the economy, technology, medical science, and the constitution. Judge-made law must respond to that change to the extent that it can properly do so.”

It is therefore clear that a paramount objective of the English legal system is to keep-pace with societal change, and thus the courts must even consider such abstract facets of our communication.

Importantly, the admission of Emojis into evidence should serve as a timely reminder that what you might consider harmless Emoji banter between friends, partners or colleagues could end up admissible evidence in Court.

Silenced by Fear: A Guide to Addressing Sexual Harassment from Those in Power

Introduction Sexual harassment can occur in many contexts, not just in the workplace. When the harasser is in a position of power—be it a manager, investor, joint venture partner, or any influential figure—it can create a climate of fear that discourages victims from...

From partners to rivals | Protecting your company using restrictive covenants

If a founder or shareholders or senior managers relationship sours, things can go wrong very quickly causing the company distraction and financial losses. This is compounded if on exit the departing individual seeks to poach clients or staff seeks to work with a...

Navigating Fashion’s Legal Landscape: Essential Guidance for Designers and Entrepreneurs

Introduction: Fashion Week is more than just runways and glamorous designs it's also a pivotal time for designers, entrepreneurs, and brands to reassess their legal strategies. As the fashion industry faces unique challenges heading into 2025, including new...

From Partners to Rivals: Protecting Your Company through restrictive covenants

Today, we’re tackling an issue that can make or break your business—restrictive covenants and their role in protecting your company during shareholder, director or staff disputes. We will touch on their importance, how these should be incorporated into your documents...

Protecting AI Innovations: Strategies and Guidelines – Part 2

As Artificial intelligence (AI) continues to evolve, its intersection with Intellectual Property (IP) law has become a crucial consideration for innovators. The UK Intellectual Property Office (IPO) has a set of detailed guidelines to evaluate if AI inventions are...

The Life of a Disruptive Lawyer: Innovating Legal Practice in Emerging Technologies ran by a Mum & Female Founder

In the staid and often stolid world of law, disruption is not a term often associated with the legal profession. Yet, at A City Law Firm , disruption is our modus operandi. From pioneering payment plans to engaging with cutting-edge technology, we have redefined what...

Protecting AI Innovations: Strategies and Guidelines – Part 1

As Artificial intelligence (AI) continues to evolve, its intersection with Intellectual Property (IP) law has become a crucial consideration for innovators. The UK Intellectual Property Office (IPO) has a set of detailed guidelines to evaluate if AI inventions are...

Tackling workplace toxicity

In today’s interconnected work environment, whether through face-to-face interactions, virtual meetings on Teams, or other communication platforms, issues such as derogatory comments, bad-mouthing employers and management, bullying and discrimination are prevalent....

Navigating the metaverse | Potential challenges for employers and employees in the UK

With the rapid advancement of technology, the concept of the metaverse is no longer confined to the realm of science fiction it is here. As virtual reality, augmented reality, and other immersive technologies converge, the metaverse is becoming increasingly tangible....

IP Licenses: When do you need one and what are the essential terms it must have?

As technology lawyers working in emerging technology, our biggest value is protecting and commercialising the founders IP The why ? In the fast-paced world of intellectual property (IP), safeguarding your creations is paramount. Whether you’re an inventor, artist, or...